John,
Thanks for the site and CrossFit Football. I have been following the training on and off for the 2 years with great results. I recently tore my ACL while competing in MMA and know you have experience with rehabbing back to full strength. I know my doctor has a conservative timeline for recovery, can you a more aggressive one?
Thanks,
G.P.
G.P. ~
Thanks for the support and glad you think enough of me to ask for direction in rehab. 20 years ago a torn ACL about ended your career, the doctor would open up your knee like he was deboning a fish, cut apart your patellar tendon to harvest a graph for the ACL, drill and use screws and staples to hold it in place. The rehab was extensive as the most of the severe damage came from cutting the knee apart for the ACL graph. Patellar tendonitis, severe knee pain, non-existent vastus lateralis and vastus medialis obliquus and about 12 months of recovery were all you had to look forward to.
Fast-forward to today and a completely different process. Doctors can perform an ACL reconstruction arthroscopically with a cadaver graft and have you back to full strength in a third of the time.
While the surgical techniques have changed, the rehab milestones have not. When you look at coming back from a major injury it is best to have milestones and small victories to keep you going.
Day 1- 6 goals: full range of motion, reduce swelling and normal gait. Full extension allows the newly reconstructed ligament to fit perfectly into the intercondylar notch. Restricting full extension will allow the notch to fill with scar tissue, block extension and never allow the muscles in the quadriceps to fully fire. Full flexion of 130+ degrees will come with time, but you should shoot for 110 degrees coming out of surgery.
Ice and compression are the key players to controlling swelling. Fred Tedeschi, trainer for the Chicago Bulls, told me the only time to not have ice on your knee was when I was training. Compression boots and socks were worn as much as possible to push swelling from the injury.
A normal gait is a smooth walking motion unimpeded by a limp. The sooner you can get off your crutches and start walking normal the faster the process of healing can begin.
You asked about a more aggressive training program and I agree many of the doctors, unless they are used to working with competitive athletes, will be very cautious. The training cannot begin until you reach full ROM, control the inflamed tissue and return to walking normal. Once you reach full terminal extension the strength and proprioceptive training can begin.
Week 2-4 goals: Full ROM, start strength training and building GPP. The majority of strength work should be done closed chained. Squatting, pulling, riding the bike, rowing and calf raises make up the majority of work. Sled pulls to build calves, hamstrings and restore some GPP.
The strength training focus becomes two fold. One, approach the same level of strength you had pre injury and create symmetry in the legs. You had better know a little bit about hypertrophy and the ability to build some leg mass as symmetry between the legs is a key factor in being cleared for full duty.
Week 4-8 goals: Full ROM, continue strength training, begin proprioceptive work and return to controlled sport specific training. Once the strength has been established in the squat and deadlift, more planes of motion are added with the lunges and step ups. Balance training also begins with the use of single leg balancing on foam blocks, two legged wobble boards and slide board.
The slide board isn’t big in CrossFit circles, but its benefits in ACL rehab is well documented. I have used the slide board in all of my knee rehabs; it has worked well for working change of direction in a controlled environment.
The doctors set rules for activity in weeks 4-6, as, no pain during or after activity, no increase in swelling and no change of gait. However, if you are training hard you will get some swelling but you have to manage the swelling with ice and compression. Changes in gait are unwanted so if you find yourself limping you have done too much.
Week 8-12 goals: full ROM including terminal extension, improved muscle tone in the quad, at least 80% of strength has returned and you should be involved in an agility/proprioceptive program geared towards returning to sport.
At this point you should be able to squat below parallel with a heavy weight. I am not expecting you to be back to squatting 600+ lbs, but you should be able to perform an Olympic style squat with a fairly heavy weight. That means knees over your toes involving the quad in the squat. A box squat with a vertical shin or negative knee angle places the stress on the hamstrings and butt. We need to start stressing the quad and the knee and preparing for more ballistic training.
Week 12+ goals: you should be approaching your pre-injury strength levels and symmetry between the two legs. The hamstrings should be strong (think steel cables), as the hamstring is the major stabilizer for the knee. You should be able to run, plant and change direction without pain or buckling.
Here is my major caveat, when doing strength training range of motion has be monitored daily to make sure you are not losing motion. If you are getting stronger and increasing tone but losing extension, then you need to look at your rehab protocol and make changes. Symmetry with ROM and strength are the keys to being back to normal.
The more diligent and hard working you are in the rehab process, the quicker you will recover. The most important part of the rehab process is to train to not have issues down the line. I have had many successful rehabs that have allowed me to come back and perform at a high level. Put in the hours and dedication in the rehab process and you should not have to deal with these injuries for years to come.
Great article, great timing. My brother has ACL surgery today.
[…] Rehabilitation after an ACL Surgery – TTMJ […]
How about an Achilles injury? I tore mine about a month and a half ago, had it surgically repaired, and with luck will be out of the walking boot next week. I’m already flat in the boot and walking on it is no problem. I’ve been doing upperbody stuff and training the other leg in the meantime. Any sugestions for rehab?
Great site John, many thanks.
First off, let me begin by saying I’m a huge fan of Crossfit, having been doing it for close to 3 years now myself. I’ve respected everyones opinions and discussions when talking about rehab or medical advice and for the most part never disagreed. However this article hits too close to home to not speak up and correct several misconceptions.
I have been in Orthopedic Surgery and Sports Medicine for 13 years and work primarily dealing with knee and shoulder injuries. So, ACL reconstructions are a mainstay to my practice. And certainaly a patient should always follow the post operative guidelines set forth by his/her Surgeon.
I think the intentions were good however the information a bit too aggressive and without appropriate basis. Current studies (AAOSM and AANA) show that autografts take up to 3 months before fully incorporated into the bone tunnels and upwards to 4 to 4.5 months for allografts. So, all the work load you describe is entirely too much cyclical and non-cocontrational load on the knee. Especially when the grafts aren’t even healled into place.
My second general concern regards further recent guidelines which also suggest holding athletes out till close to 6 months before any rotational or cut/pivot events. This allows full graft incorporation, full quad and hamstring function, and completion of proprioception conditioning. So, when you suggest that by week 12 one could “plant and change direction” is alarming to me and completely against our recommendations to our patients.
Again, please don’t consider my remarks as condescending, but instead trying to further help our wonderful Crossfit communities knowledge base. Happy to discuss or debate this topic further with you at any time.
Hank Casagrande
Great post…definitely an aggressive recovery plan not for everyone but if you didn’t have too much damage and you did your physio diligently a recovery this quick is possible. Great exercises to do since they all also increase your balance. Thanks for the post.
[…] Rehabilitation after an ACL Surgery – TTMJ […]
John et al……………………..add that all orthopods are NOT created equal. Vast diff in skill and experience level, and hence results, even with sports docs. I’ve had both acl’s replaced. First was “the knee doctor of Europe”, Dr. Jurgen Eichorn. Performed a seldom done “double bundle” technique. At year 1, physically and psychologically i could tell zero diff from original knee. Flash forware to knee number 2. Done use olograph and traditonal technique by sports, board certified orthopod. 1 year later, loose and no better than before.
Bottom line, choose carefully you doc. That is the single most important factor. If that tendon is not either 1) pulled very tight making full extension a serious month long intense effort, it will loosen up and you will be no better off. 2) Use double bundle as it more closely mirrors the original acl.
Deano
Second Paragraph under 8 – 12 weeks:
“…A box with a vertical shit or negative knee angle places the stress on the hamstrings…”
Are we talking vertical shift here or something different?
Fixed.
I wish I would have had this article 6 years ago when I tore my ACL the first time! Now, due to a soccer injury 2 months ago, I am scheduled for surgery to remove my blown Cadaver Achilles tendon from my knee as well as meniscus trimming and tibial tunnel bone grafting. Apparently it is a fairly easy surgery with a quick recovery. 6 months from now I will be able to go back in for my second ACL replacement if I so choose. I have been told that I may opt to not get another ACL replacement if I feel that I gain enough stability through strengthening my knee. Im 34, I play recreational soccer with a CTi brace, I lift weights and compete in the Highland games (novice level and all for fun). If I decide not to get a new ACL, what would be the best way for me to ensure that my knee area is the strongest it can be?
Thanks for your always wise insight!
Good stuff about post surgical acl rehab. Now what about functioning with a torn acl? Any suggestions about training, rehab and such?
Really enjoy your website and contribution to crossfit and the s&c world!
Thanks
Thea
[…] Rehab after ACL surgery […]
[…] to Ride Your First Motorcycle Training Your Extensors for Performance Concentration True Privilege Rehabilitation After an ACL Surgery June 11th, 2011 | Category: […]
wow….
I had my ACL torn in january earlier this year while playing basketball. Had my surgery on February 18th, and was off crutches in a couple of weeks.
When I was reading your article, I was so shocked. First off, a 12 week recovery plan?! That sounds crazy, because full range of motion for me, was acquired at around the third month after surgery (but that was after my manipulation, and it should’ve been full ROM at 2 months). But still, full ROM at 1-6 days! Wow, if that’s what you or anyone else has done, I’m impressed; the pain must’ve been unimaginable.
Second, have you heard about the hamstring grafts? That’s what I had for my left knee, since the ideal recovery is around 6 months, but 9 months for a cadaver. Supposedly, it’s twice as strong since the hamstring piece is folded in half and placed in.
And thirdly. I need some advice; I’m at nearly 5 months, running a mile a day and my school athletic trainer tells me that I have another 3 to 4 months before playing soccer or basketball! As any athlete can imagine, that’s way too long. I’m waiting a month at the most, because soccer season is starting around then. Basketball starts in November, but I need soccer to get me ready.
The question is, what should I be doing for recovery, as I am a Junior in high school and a 16-year-old girl… in about a month plan?
[…] Rehabilitation after an ACL Surgery – TTMJ […]
The Doctor explained both the cadavar graft and the patellar graft to me and gave me the pros and cons for both. I ended up going with the patellar tendon graft and am currently 4 weeks post op. I just had therapy this morning and I did my first full rotation on the stationary bike. Extension is at 1 degree on my own and flexion is at 110 on my own.
I would say if you were an athlete totally in shape you would be so much further along than me. I tore my ACL trying to get back in shape and because I’m not in shape the road is that much longer.
What scared me about the cadavar graft was the possibility for a disease being transmitted and the fact that I have no idea whose body part I’d be getting. The Doc would try to find a tissue close to my age or younger but who the heck knows what I’d actually get. So I went with my own tissue.
I’ve just resigned to the fact that I probably won’t be playing much softball next season and be riding my bike and swimming a lot instead.
I committed a mistake by keeping a pillow under my knee after acl surgery for 4-5 days.
Will it affect my knee in any way?
please reply asap